Glycosmedia

Diabetes News Service

Privacy & Cookies: This site uses cookies. By continuing to use this website, you agree to their use.
To find out more, including how to control cookies, see here: Cookies Policy
  • News
  • Archive
  • Categories & Tags
  • Journal Watch
  • Updates
  • Education
  • Reviews
  • About us ▼
    • About Glycosmedia
    • Editorial Team
    • Frequently asked questions
    • Comments
    • Press Releases
    • Disclaimer
  • Subscribe
  • Contact

Book and Product Reviews

If you are interested in sponsoring the Reviews section, then please contact the editor Jim Young - jim@glycosmedia.com



The Story of Pain: From Prayer to Painkillers

May 30th 2014

Reviewed by Jim Young

Joanna Bourke

Published by Oxford University Press

ISSBN: 978-0-19-968942-2

Price £20

http://ukcatalogue.oup.com/product/9780199689422.do

The evocation of the experience of pain is the fulcrum of the lever used by sufferers, carers, and physicians to understand the phenomenon of pain.

How pain is perceived by these parties is a product of the expressions used to describe pain, the etymology of which is driven by the contemporary psychosocial mores unique to each milieu.

This book employs uncompromisingly academic reasoning to explore these mores and asks what pain is? Does it exist as an external entity? Or is it endogenous? For both the sufferer and the observer the question arises: are the perceptions of- and the associated attitudes to pain unavoidably subjective?

An etymological approach to the description of pain was an unexpected inception – but then again why should it be? The words, analogies and metaphors that were used constitute the historical signposts that describe and reflect contemporary understanding of physiology and of developments in society.

But it is not only the etymology of the words used to communicate the experience of pain “as an event” that is explored in Professor Bourke’s book, but also the irrepressible need to communicate the experience of pain. The corollary of which is the changing perception by the physician as to how much of a free-flowing pain narrative really needs to be expropriated for diagnosis and treatment to be optimised; and this perception is continually changing as “scientific” diagnostic procedures evolve.

The book is not a medical history as such but an all-encompassing elucidation of the history of the interpretation of experience of pain. It explores the dynamic interconnections between language and culture that colours the perception of the sensation of pain and the cognition that ensues.

The discursive discourse is replete with historical quotations from philosophers, physicians and from people in pain. The influence of the ubiquitous effects of religious belief and the perceived role of sin in pain, and the subsequent secular backlash, are not omitted.

The perception of pain as an essential compass for diagnosis is examined alongside the gradual diminution of the importance of the pain narrative as a diagnostic tool. A fascinating proposal is floated that the role of the pain narrative is shrinking and may be eliciting less trust by the physician. Starting from the time when sympathy was all that a physician could offer, the book pans to the present day where MRI scans, drugs, or surgery provide diagnosis and effective treatment, and where the psycho-therapeutic effect of a sympathetic demeanour, in response to an effusive narrative of pain may be reduced.

The book is exhaustively annotated and offers a large bibliography.

Although my first exploration of the unexpected parameters of the experience of pain was enthralling, I intend immediately re-reading the book in the expectation that the experience will be enriched from the perspective gained from my first excursion through this intriguing Story of Pain.

Jim Young

May 2014

Categories: Book and Product Reviews

Reviews Archive

calendar-iconReviews Archive ››

Subscribe

subscribe-iconFREE weekly updates by email Please CLICK HERE

Platinum Sponsors

Boehringer Ingelheim Lilly

Gold Sponsors

AstraZenecaNapp DiabetesSanofi DiabetesNovo Nordisk

Silver Sponsors

Abbott Diabetes CareAmgenWelsh Endocrinology and Diabetes Society (WEDS)

FUNDING NOTICE

The Glycosmedia website and newsletter has been made possible with funding support from our sponsors. None of our sponsors have control over the content of the website, newsletter, apps, Twitter feed or RSS newsfeed.

For information about sponsorship and advertising please contact our editor-in-chief Jim Young jim@glycosmedia.com

Advertisers

CRC Press

The organisations advertising in this section do not have any input into, or editorial control over the content of this website.

Join us on Facebook

Join us on Facebook

Please share Glycosmedia:

Follow us on Twitter

My Tweets

mobileGlycosmedia is also available as an App:

For iPhone and iPad | For Android devices


Sponsorship and Advertising

For information about sponsorship and advertising please contact our editor-in-chief Jim Young jim@glycosmedia.com

Copyright © 2021 Glycosmedia Partnership